Curse redirect

[Timb1234]

I had an item that made me immune to curses played by other players.

Another player had a card that would let him redirect a curse he was hit with to another player. He asked if he could redirect a curse at me or if I would be immune.

I said it depended on the source of the curse; if he kicked the door and got a curse he could redirect it at me since I am not immune to curses from kicking the door, but if it was a curse played by another player then I would be immune to it.

He felt that I shouldn't be immune to it either way since I wasn't really getting hit by the curse but rather by the card he would be playing.

I said that him playing the card caused me to get hit by a curse but I was still getting hit by a curse, and would still have immunity depending on the source of the curse.

So who was right?