Treasures with Polymorph Potion and Ancient +10 to Monster

ohho · 01-01-2014, 08:51 PM

We have a question regarding Polymorph Potion and Ancient +10 to Monster. A player was facing a monster that would give 2 treasures when I added the Ancient +10 to Monster card, which states 2 extra treasures would be dropped if the monster is defeated. The player then used a Polymorph Potion that turned the monster into a bird that flies away leaving the treasure behind.

I argue that because the bird flies away and is not defeated, then only the 2 original treasures should be rewarded. The player thinks differently and think the treasure the bird leaves behind includes the two from the ancient +10.

Any advice?

01-01-2014, 08:51 PM	#1
ohho Join Date: Jan 2014	Treasures with Polymorph Potion and Ancient +10 to Monster We have a question regarding Polymorph Potion and Ancient +10 to Monster. A player was facing a monster that would give 2 treasures when I added the Ancient +10 to Monster card, which states 2 extra treasures would be dropped if the monster is defeated. The player then used a Polymorph Potion that turned the monster into a bird that flies away leaving the treasure behind. I argue that because the bird flies away and is not defeated, then only the 2 original treasures should be rewarded. The player thinks differently and think the treasure the bird leaves behind includes the two from the ancient +10. Any advice?