Health Club

[kosbour]

How can the Health Club lose its magic and remain a non-magical +2 club?

[Clipper]

Originally Posted by kosbour

How can the Health Club lose its magic and remain a non-magical +2 club?

From a room or effect that says magical Items do not count, such as the Anti-Magic Room.

[MunchkinMan]

Originally Posted by kosbour

How can the Health Club lose its magic and remain a non-magical +2 club?

Coldly Rational, a Monster Enhancer, says you can't use Magic Items, nor get any benefit from those that aren't combat oriented, against that Monster. Anti-Magic Room, too, says that all Magic Items lose their bonuses and special powers.

In both cases, you'd lose the Health Marker, but get to keep the +2 combat bonus.