08-24-2020, 02:37 PM | #1 |
Join Date: Nov 2014
|
Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
Back when I first got into GURPS, I bought Magic 3E and Grimoire at a bookstore since I had heard it had much the same material as 4E GURPS Magic. I did later eventually get a softcover copy of 4E, but I occasionally would wonder what changed between the two editions.
The last week or so I went through my each spell in GURPS Magic 3E and Grimoire and compared the text to what was in 4E, and logged the meaningful differences that I spotted on a spreadsheet. There are quite a bit more than I expected. I tried to only list the changes with game mechanical effects. Often there was clarifying language added, I only listed it if I felt it were important to the understanding on how the spell worked. Some spells had many more differences than could be covered in one cell. I usually noted them as large/various differences. They are usually the type of spells that need heavy GM oversight anyway. I figured I would post the link here in case anyone in the future was interested or would find it useful. EDIT: I added a new tab that lists the differences between 4E and the DFRPG spells. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...7GPsa1r-Q2PQsM Interesting differences in 3E- Steal Attribute, Steal Skill, and Steal Beauty could be made permanent. The cumulative penalty for Relieve Addiction was only -1 per day. There was no cumulative penalty for Vigil. Essential Food is VH. I think this is the only spell that changed difficulty. (This was fixed via errata. Fixed on the sheet.) Terror is 4 times as cheap and penalizes the Fright Check more. Create Food couldn't create food ex nihilo. Last edited by Overheat; 10-05-2021 at 08:57 PM. |
08-24-2020, 03:48 PM | #2 |
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: South Dakota, USA
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
I haven't had a chance to look through this yet, but thanks!
__________________
My GURPS Fourth Edition library consists of Basic Set: Characters, Basic Set: Campaigns, Martial Arts, Powers, Powers: Enhanced Senses, Power-Ups 1: Imbuements, Power-Ups 2: Perks, Power-Ups 3: Talents, Power-Ups 4: Enhancements, Power-Ups 6: Quirks, Power-Ups 8: Limitations, Powers, Social Engineering, Supers, Template Toolkit 1: Characters, Template Toolkit 2: Races, one issue of Pyramid (3/83) a.k.a. Alternate GURPS IV, GURPS Classic Rogues, and GURPS Classic Warriors. Most of which was provided through the generosity of others. Thanks! :) |
08-24-2020, 05:55 PM | #3 |
Join Date: Jan 2017
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
I think the Magic 4e errata lists Essential Food as VH.
|
08-24-2020, 08:29 PM | #4 |
Join Date: Apr 2005
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
Interesting. Thanks for the spreadsheet.
You should consider doing the Enchantment college spells, since there were some substantial changes. In particular, any enchantments dealing with PD (e.g., Deflect) went away. As another project, consider comparing GURPS 4E spells to GURPS Dungeon Fantasy and DFRPG spells. IMO, Magic 4E was a rush job which ignored 10+ years of fan feedback regarding which spells were broken and how they should be fixed (GURPS Magic 1E was for GURPS 2E and came out in the late 1980s - 1987 or 1988, IRC). Many of the recommended fixes only happened when GURPS Magic was ported over to Dungeon Fantasy and then DFRPG. If you want to fix problems with GURPS 3E magic, you will need to dig way into the weeds try to find the GURPS-L Listserv and rec.game.rpg.gurps Usenet archives, which still preserve some of the commonly recommended changes at the time. A really careful crawl through the GURPS forum will also catch a number of complaints and recommended fixes, especially ca. 2003-2005. Some of the older surviving fan-based material on the web also proposes fixes for stock Magic 3E spells. One of the larger attempts is here: http://patyrsun.tripod.com/magic.htm This is, essentially, a really ancient version of my Codex Arcanum, minus Mind Control spells (which never made it on to the quaint little pre-21st century World Wide Web) and with the serial numbers filed off. It incorporates all the more intelligent suggestions for fixing problematic spells made prior to about 1999. |
08-24-2020, 09:10 PM | #5 | |
Join Date: Aug 2007
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
Quote:
Penetrating Blade underwent big changes. It's so good now that we probably need a Hardened Defense spell. In 3e you used to be able to make a Sword of Everbleeding Wounds but the Enchantment version of that went away in 4e. A very nice Enchantment version of Stop Bleeding showed up instead so I guess 4e is just sort of anti-bleeding.
__________________
Fred Brackin |
|
08-25-2020, 06:37 AM | #6 |
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Ronkonkoma, NY
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
I found the biggest change to be not the details of the spells but the specific lists available in the Basic Set. The fourth edition took away the Animal and Making and Breaking colleges, and added Body Control, Gate, Meta, Movement, Necromantic, and Protection and Warning colleges. In itself this isn't a problem, but there are issues when trying to use third-edition source books that tell you that the spell list of the Basic Set is an appropriate base for a particular type of spellcaster. Unless you write a new spell list based on the third-edition Basic Set, you're getting the wrong list.
|
08-25-2020, 08:34 AM | #7 | |
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Seattle, Washington
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
Quote:
__________________
Natural Encyclopedia: 660 GURPS bestiary entries It Came from the Forums: A Community Bestiary with 160 entries (last updated 2009...someday I will revisit.) |
|
08-25-2020, 09:39 AM | #8 | |
GURPS Line Editor
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Montréal, Québec
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
Quote:
The issue was that GURPS Magic was in in revision and editing while I was still 100% occupied with the Basic Set, Fourth Edition. Immediately after that, I was set to organizing all the hardbacks we had promised. I never got a chance to review Magic. As a result, it didn't get a review from one of exactly two people in the world – David Pulver and myself – who were fully aware of all the edition changes at the time. The compiler had to muddle through with an almost two-year-old first draft of the Basic Set, which changed considerably during a long and rigorous review process. Thus, there was in a sense a "version-control issue" that affected the compiler, but that was with the Basic Set, not Magic. If the compiler or someone else said that they worked up a revised draft that was more in tune with the Basic Set as finally released, they might well have been telling the truth. However, that would have been well after both the Basic Set and Magic were released!
__________________
Sean "Dr. Kromm" Punch <kromm@sjgames.com> GURPS Line Editor, Steve Jackson Games My DreamWidth [Just GURPS News] |
|
08-25-2020, 01:34 PM | #9 |
Banned
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bristol
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
I think the shift from PD to DB was great. Is there or will there be a sort of rule of thumb for conversion to DB, this may help converting vehicles too?
|
08-25-2020, 01:36 PM | #10 | ||
Join Date: Aug 2018
|
Re: Differences between 3E and 4E Magic spells
One major change between systems is probably that you can't do half-point skills anymore. Some semblance of that was introduced in Magical Styles with "Wizardly Dabbler" but that only works on no-prereqs starter spells.
Of course, if you're also using that perk which lets spells default to each other at -4 (plus prereqs) then you could use standard Dabbler mechanics to buy off those penalties, but the outcome is not particularly impressive compared to just sinking a point in. Quote:
Quote:
Another basis for comparison would be the functionality of rituals in 3e's zombies/spirits compared to 4e's thaumatology. I know Spirit Slave got a slight tweak in terms of what traits are applied. |
||
Tags |
magic |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|