Loaded/reloaded Die question

[AaronSan]

Ok Bob makes a roll,
Jim uses a reloaded die to make the roll different
Can Susan use a loaded die to change the reloaded outcome?

[Progmode]

Yes, this is allowed.

[MunchkinMan]

Originally Posted by Progmode

Yes, this is allowed.

Hmmmm. . . A Reloaded Die, definitely. I wouldn't be so sure about a Loaded Die. Bob rolled, not Susan, and I would think that who rolled still matters to the playing of those cards. I will consult with the PTB to determine intent whether overrides override the "who rolled" clause.

[Cheese8242]

Originally Posted by Progmode

Yes, this is allowed.

Actually, In that situation Susan could not use a "loaded die" to change the out come. Since Bob was the person to roll the die he would be the only person able to use a loaded die card, not Susan. Susan could use another Reloaded die card to further change the outcome of Jim's Reloaded die, but not the loaded die card.

[Progmode]

Originally Posted by Cheese8242

Actually, In that situation Susan could not use a "loaded die" to change the out come. Since Bob was the person to roll the die he would be the only person able to use a loaded die card, not Susan. Susan could use another Reloaded die card to further change the outcome of Jim's Reloaded die, but not the loaded die card.

Doh, card game logic fails at board game logic. I got confused which forum I was in. Disregard my statement.

[morleydotes]

Originally Posted by Progmode

Disregard my statement.

Do that at your own risk...

I don't disregard anything he says, I just ignore it when he's wrong. So, maybe every 25 or so posts...


;-)