[Basic/LT/MA]Disarm with Whips

[Gigermann]

For Disarming, non-fencing weapons get a -2. Whips are listed as getting a +2 for Disarm attempts. Are these two conditions cumulative (being effectively negated) or does the Whip bonus override the non-fencing penalty?

[Imion]

You have an extra -2 to hit unless you use a fencing weapon

If you hit and your foe fails to defend, roll a Quick Contest of weapon skills with your foe (...) You get +2 if you use Jitte/Sai or Whip skill (having it is not enough!).

both B401

Emphases mine.

[Gigermann]

Originally Posted by Imion

both B401

Ah, good point