Immunity to Break Weapon

[Shostak]

Originally Posted by warhorse11h

As I stated previously, that sentence can also be interpreted to mean that a weapon that has been enchanted is by its nature given immunity to Break
Weapons.

One problem with this view is that it is contradicted by the description of Master Armorer. Here we learn that a Master Armorer will always recognize a magic weapon, but will need to succeed on a 4/IQ roll to recognize immunity to Drop and Break Weapon (or any other specific enchantment). If all magic weapons are immune, then surely a Master Armorer would not need to recognize immunity with a roll. But they do. So weapons with that immunity must be a subset of all magical weapons.