metal shields

[Crakkerjakk]

Originally Posted by dripton

So if you're using both DF and MA, and you sharpen the edge of a dwarven shield, does that swing-2 cutting damage get +1 for bashing with a dwarven shield? Or does only the traditional crushing kind of shield bash get +1 from a dwarven shield?

I'd rule you could bash at sw-1 with the edge.

Originally Posted by dripton

Also, if a metal shield has both a sharp edge and a spike, and you hit with the edge for cutting damage, do you get +1 for the spike? (I think the answer to this one is obvious, but I figured I'd ask it just for completeness.)

No. You're correct, the answer is obvious. ;-)