attribute modifier vs/or xd6 rolls

[TippetsTX]

Originally Posted by sekalo

I do not have ITL, and I would not expect the crit success would change. By moving the crit target number, is keeping the same % inline with 3d6. 5- is 4.62 on 3d6. 8- 5.40%. For the crit failure on 4d6 is roughly the same percentage compared to 3d6. That is what i find so confusing.

I actually agree which is why I changed the thresholds for my own game.

IMO, if the inherent difficulty of a task is greater then so are the odds of a critical failure (and the reverse for critical success).