"Blocking" shields vs damage reduction shields

[RobW]

Originally Posted by TippetsTX

Which I believe is the more accurate simulation even in the abstract. And even w/o the math, my players feel like a shield is a more desirable option now.

They have certainly grown to appreciate their effectiveness when they engage opponents using shields.
;)

What you're doing seems like a easy way to increase your players' survivability. Hope it was interesting to see the effects above.