Remembrall for non-item cards

Airblader · 05-25-2021, 12:26 AM

We were playing the Harry Potter edition of Munchkin the other night, and in my fight to win the game someone wanted to use "Remembrall" to pick up "Finite" from the discards to force-end my fight.

Remembrall reads "Search the Treasure discards for any card worth 300 Gold or less", Finite is a one-shot treasure card with no printed value, not even "No value", i.e. it's not an item. The question is: how do non-items compare against the gold requirement?

My guess was that this is a misprint, and the card should be restricted to "item" rather than "card". I also argued that you can't just treat cards not having any value the same as "0 Gold", even more so since "No value" cards specifically exist for this already. They ended up ruling against me, and I demand justice! :-)

05-25-2021, 12:26 AM	#1
Airblader Join Date: May 2021	Remembrall for non-item cards We were playing the Harry Potter edition of Munchkin the other night, and in my fight to win the game someone wanted to use "Remembrall" to pick up "Finite" from the discards to force-end my fight. Remembrall reads "Search the Treasure discards for any card worth 300 Gold or less", Finite is a one-shot treasure card with no printed value, not even "No value", i.e. it's not an item. The question is: how do non-items compare against the gold requirement? My guess was that this is a misprint, and the card should be restricted to "item" rather than "card". I also argued that you can't just treat cards not having any value the same as "0 Gold", even more so since "No value" cards specifically exist for this already. They ended up ruling against me, and I demand justice! :-)