What do you experience under the Enthrall spell?

[Pbuckley]

Originally Posted by Plane

Being attacked means automatically breaking free
Being "shaken" means getting 1 new resistance roll per second of being "disturbed"

Would be useful to mechanically define the differences between these two things a little better.

Like for example you technically "attack" to grapple someone, either by hand or by rope, no? To "shake" someone sounds like you're either using a Shove attack, or "Shoving People Around" after a grapple...

If you're in a daze, you probably can't perceive a lot of attacks (some attacks are surprise to begin with) so is that maybe a supernatural effect (the SPELL knows they're being attacked, and breaks them free) or would it actually require a Per roll by the enthralled to understand an attack is happening?

Some attacks may not even be normally perceptible, like if you get hit with some No Wounding attack w/ a Side Effect, or certain No Signature enhanced Afflictions.

My experience with effects like this would suggest that taking damage is what snaps you out of the effect. It's like a shock to your system. But maybe I need to read the spell again.

[Plane]

Originally Posted by Pbuckley

My experience with effects like this would suggest that taking damage is what snaps you out of the effect. It's like a shock to your system. But maybe I need to read the spell again.

it doesn't mention injury, only attack. Doesn't even say the attack needs to hit.

I definitely like the idea of this being linked to shock (which I guess might be a bad thing for those with High Pain Threshold, good thing for Low Pain Threshold?)

sometime like for each -1 you would suffer maybe you get +5 or +10 to snap out of it? You could avoid rolling once that exceeds 15 per 'riding a bike' TDM