Atlantean sword argument

[Hobbs5212]

So if a card is protected from bad stuff and curses, you lose the ability to volunteer it in response to bad stuff and curses?

If you need to lose a a hand item or you lose level and you item can be lost to bad stuff then you can't lose it.

And...

In this case the sword itself isn't being targeted directly, the player should be able to sacrifice anything they want to meet the 500 coin reqtuirment. That's what is meant by proxy. The curse isn't taking your sword away you are choosing to give it up.

If this is thought of in the "real world" you owe a guy 500 coins worth of stuff and you have a pair of boots and a sword. As the owner of the sword you should be able to go hey here is "MY" sword you can have it. It's protection from bad stuff or curses is being used as a negative modifier by the line moderator. That doesn't make sense if you think of yourself as a adventurer in a dungeon faced with the problem.

It's my item