Dungeon Fantasy RPG All-Out Attack (Double) Question

[evileeyore]

Originally Posted by sir_pudding

I don't understand why you find this convoluted interpretation and proliferation of nuisance rolls to be preferrable to Extra Effort in Combat. It isn't like you only have the DFRPG.

I don't. However one is "RAW DFRPG"* and one isn't.

One is "working within the framework of the box set"* and one is "adding things from outside the box set".

Also one is "interesting mental exercise"* and one is "simple, easy, and basically already done".



* If you're referring to the thread I started four months ago. I mean I could go back to that thread and post an addendum of "I tried it, it's stupid, don't do this, use Extra Effort In Combat from Basic instead" if that helps.

Of course if you recall from that thread I didn't want more rolling... I was creating a "figure this stuff out before combat and it costs 1 or more FP for these results" system.