"History Repeats Itself!"

[MunchkinMan]

For what it's worth, the phrase "top {card type} in the discard pile" always means the first card of that card type from the top of the appropriate discard pile. Otherwise, the card would have to say "on top," like Daredevil found in Munchkin Apocalypse 2:Sheep Impact, does in its Adrenaline Junkie ability.