Spaceships 7 and Cannon/Catapult Damage

[David Johnston2]

Originally Posted by cvannrederode

So it seems to me that there's something going on in SS, or else the cannon damage is very broken.

A 12 cm cannon from SS does 6dx30 dDamage, multiplied by speed in mps. So 6dx300(2) p++ (non-decade) at 1 mps (or 5280 fps, ~ 1600 m/s)

The D-81TM TL Russian tank cannon is in High Tech. It's 125 mm, or 12.5 cm. And it's damage, with APFSDS, is 6dx30(2) p++. It's muzzle velocity, according to wiki, is 1700 to 1800 m/s, or better than one mps.

What is being used to justify the order of magnitude increase?

The difference in scale between 1 second and ten minutes. While most of that time is simply occupied with trying to get within range, it's still a lot more bombardment than a single second's shooting.

[acrosome]

No, I think his quote of the errata is correct:

I have the updated PDF and decade damage for 12cm is listed as 6dx3 on p.68.

(By the way, if you still have the old PDF you can download the new one for free.)

[Ulzgoroth]

Originally Posted by cvannrederode

So it seems to me that there's something going on in SS, or else the cannon damage is very broken.

A 12 cm cannon from SS does 6dx30 dDamage, multiplied by speed in mps. So 6dx300(2) p++ (non-decade) at 1 mps (or 5280 fps, ~ 1600 m/s)

The D-81TM TL Russian tank cannon is in High Tech. It's 125 mm, or 12.5 cm. And it's damage, with APFSDS, is 6dx30(2) p++. It's muzzle velocity, according to wiki, is 1700 to 1800 m/s, or better than one mps.

What is being used to justify the order of magnitude increase?

Yeah, it's errata as FenrisLoki points out, and it's in current versions of the PDF.

Originally Posted by David Johnston2

The difference in scale between 1 second and ten minutes. While most of that time is simply occupied with trying to get within range, it's still a lot more bombardment than a single second's shooting.

No. The damage in question is for one shot. (And couldn't possibly be otherwise in GURPS. DR applies per shot, so damage has to be given the same way.)