Exalted: something broken, or just different power level?

mlangsdorf · 01-02-2013, 03:17 PM

The system is probably more mechanical complex than would be desirable for a high-powered, semi-narrative game. It also has some obvious issues, like expecting people to routinely roll 15+ dice in their die pools. Weapon damage for even medium range weapons without charm usage is absurdly high compared to armor and health, making combat unreasonably deadly. There's a huge gap between what the fluff says a character's ability should be and the game mechanical representation. The charm trees are bloated, non-intuitive, and hard to remember, which leads to NPCs being nearly unplayable.

And all of that should be pretty obvious just from reading the core book, creating a few characters, and running some test encounters.

I'd say the game is difficult to play as it is. Supposedly, the errata is making things better, but there's a lot of fundamental concepts that make extended campaign play difficult.

01-02-2013, 03:17 PM	#2
mlangsdorf Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Austin, TX	Re: Exalted: something broken, or just different power level? The system is probably more mechanical complex than would be desirable for a high-powered, semi-narrative game. It also has some obvious issues, like expecting people to routinely roll 15+ dice in their die pools. Weapon damage for even medium range weapons without charm usage is absurdly high compared to armor and health, making combat unreasonably deadly. There's a huge gap between what the fluff says a character's ability should be and the game mechanical representation. The charm trees are bloated, non-intuitive, and hard to remember, which leads to NPCs being nearly unplayable. And all of that should be pretty obvious just from reading the core book, creating a few characters, and running some test encounters. I'd say the game is difficult to play as it is. Supposedly, the errata is making things better, but there's a lot of fundamental concepts that make extended campaign play difficult.