Super Munchkin Sidekick Question

shorty · 11-26-2011, 08:57 PM

Let me set the stage for this scenario. Today we were playing Super Munchkin. I had a Sidekick I really loved in play. I also had a sidekick in my hand. No other sidekicks were in play by any other players. For whatever reason I drew the treasure card "Accidentally Off a Sidekick." The card reads:

You can use this card ONLY if a Sidekick is in play (no matter who owns him). Discard a sidekick of your choice. GO UP A LEVEL

Here's my question... I understand it says to USE the card at least one sidekick must be in play. But then it says "Discard a sidekick of YOUR CHOICE." It doesnt say it MUST be the sidekick in play it just says a sidekick of your choice. So can I discard the one I had in my hand with this card to go up a level? We argued and I lost the arguement because I was outnumber. They were insisting that I had to discard my sidekick that was in play. What do you think?

11-26-2011, 08:57 PM	#1
shorty Join Date: Nov 2011	Super Munchkin Sidekick Question Let me set the stage for this scenario. Today we were playing Super Munchkin. I had a Sidekick I really loved in play. I also had a sidekick in my hand. No other sidekicks were in play by any other players. For whatever reason I drew the treasure card "Accidentally Off a Sidekick." The card reads: You can use this card ONLY if a Sidekick is in play (no matter who owns him). Discard a sidekick of your choice. GO UP A LEVEL Here's my question... I understand it says to USE the card at least one sidekick must be in play. But then it says "Discard a sidekick of YOUR CHOICE." It doesnt say it MUST be the sidekick in play it just says a sidekick of your choice. So can I discard the one I had in my hand with this card to go up a level? We argued and I lost the arguement because I was outnumber. They were insisting that I had to discard my sidekick that was in play. What do you think?