Conflicting Disads - Cannot Harm Innocent's and Honesty

[Figleaf23]

Originally Posted by Mailanka

Self-Defense only. It's right there.

Look, you've got four versions:

1. Cannot attack or kill anyone
2. Cannot kill anyone (but may attack)
3. Cannot attack anyone not already attacking you (but may kill)
4. Cannot kill anyone not already attacking you

Now, you can call those what you want, but they called #4 "Cannot harm innocents." To be unable to attack/enslave someone who hasn't first tried to put a bullet in your head, you want #3 (aka Self-Defense Only).

Self-Defense Only: You only fight to
defend yourself or those in your care,
using only as much force as necessary
(no pre-emptive strikes allowed!). You
must do your best to discourage others
from starting fights. -15 points.

This is not the same as what I'm talking about.

It does not cover a person who can proactively go after bad-guys, but cannot harm innocents.