Conflicting Disads - Cannot Harm Innocent's and Honesty

[Figleaf23]

Originally Posted by Mailanka

...If you want "I can't even attack you unless you attack me," you take "Pacifism: Self Defense Only," which is worth more than Cannot Harm Innocents.

If you want "I can't do anything to someone truly good," then you'd take total pacisifm with the modifier "Only against the truly good and innocent."

Neither of those things is what we are talking about.

What is missing is something that actually prevents the character from harming persons uninvolved in their conflict. Speculations about persons' 'goodness' is beside the point.

But you're right that any missing flavour of pacifism could be based off Total Pacifism with GM-generated limitations, but that's a general truism.