Dungeon Fantasy needs a bare-bones setting

[maximara]

Originally Posted by Tyneras

I would go for worked dungeons and encounters, but I don't think that a specific setting designed for DF would be a good idea. That would just constrain the creativity of both the setting and future DF books. If you have a setting, just make notes for how this or that would work if you play DF using that setting, or retrofit it with a supplement like DF: Banestorm or DF: Madlands.

I disagree as D&D had Greyhawk as its defacto setting but that didn't stop settings like Forgotten Realms and SpellJammer from coming into being.

SpellJammer is a very good example because it is basically a TL (3+2)^ to TL (3+3)^ setting where you are flying ships between planets (though interstellar travel is not possible). If D&D could come up with THAT even though Greyhawk existed then why would DF be constrained by a default setting?