Are quirks officially counted as disadvantages?

[trooper6]

Originally Posted by jeff_wilson

When personal offense is taken at a criticism of a *choice*that people are free to make or not, to recognize that offense as valid is to make claims of victimhood a tool for silencing dissent.

Making statements that those who GM in a style that you don't like are bad GMs is a way of silencing dissent. Calling people out on that isn't.

There is a difference between an attack and a critique.

"Anyone who does X is an antagonistic GM" is not a critique.

ETA: Also note, I'm not saying, "Ze stop talking," I'm just asking him to communicate his ideas in a less attacky sort of way. It is possible to talk about the positives of having no disad limits with out name calling people who do something different.