Quote:
Originally Posted by phayman53
As a result of this, membership in the Armsman's Guild requires at least Code of Honor (Stay's Bought) [-5] and a Minor Vow [-5]
....
Less scrupulous member do exist who lack the mandatory disadvantages, instead they have a -10 point secret.
|
Is that really an appropriate requirement? Code of Honor and Vow require you to have a personal commitment to the cause, which you would not willingly break even in the face of death. Secret (I might betray my oath under a hypothetical situation that hasn't so far occurred) isn't really suitable. Secret (I have betrayed/regularly betray my oath) is.
So there is daylight between the two extremes.