Steve Jackson Games Forums - GURPS Power-Ups 1 is out

Quote:

Originally Posted by dataweaver

3 is a special case of 2 (Follow-Up is an Enhancement), just as changing damage type is a special case of switching out one attack Advantage for another.

No, 3 is not a special case of 2: by "a Follow-Up" I meant "An attack, affliction, etc., with the Follow-Up enhancement", not "the Follow-Up enhancement". None of the Imbuements add the Follow-up enhancement to an existing attack, some add another attack with Follow-up to an existing attack.

Quote:

+50% of what?

+50% is the value of this special version of the Follow-Up enhancement

Quote:

How is this even as good as what PU1 provides, let alone better?

"Good" in what sense? Its "good" (and "better" than PU1) in the ability to leverage just about any effect that you would want as an enhancement to the weapons effect that can be created with points-based abilities, whereas PU1 gives you a GURPS Magic-style spell list.

Quote:

And how is it in keeping with GURPS Powers?

How is it not?

Quote:

FWIW, GURPS Powers - indeed, Basic Set - already has a mechanism for being able to switch out one attack advantage for another; it's called an Alternate Attack.

A weapon isn't "an attack advantage", since it is not bought with points.

Quote:

If you're wanting to work within the GURPS Powers framework as you say, shouldn't you be using something along those lines as the analog of the Transforming Imbuement skills?

If you wanted to buy all weapons as gadget-based powers, sure; but then if you did that, there is no need for any extension to Powers at all, you just use Powers as-is with no extensions. OTOH, if you wanted to handle what Imbuements handles, while ignoring the factors it ignores (notably, the value of the weapon it modifies as an attack), while building an advantage-based system for modifying mundane weapons that fits structurally in with Powers and lets you leverage point-based GURPS abilities for the enhancement effects, you would do something other than Alternate Attacks/Abilities. What I present is one way do that. Its not the only one, and it may not be the best.