Originally Posted by Skarg (Post 1949638)

The first GURPS combat rules (Man to Man, first edition, maybe 2nd edition) had a Stop Thrust (optional?) rule, which is basically that if you've got a ready thrusting hand weapon which can parry, and someone advances towards you into range, you can use a parry as a stop thrust attack during their movement, which if it hits and they fail to defend (obviously if they use a Retreat defense, that stops their forward move), does maximum damage.

Originally Posted by Tomsdad (Post 1949580)

I think the issue with parrying heavy object breaking your weapon, is unless you are actually physically attached to your weapon, your grip will be weaker then your weapon which means your grip will 'break/fail' before your weapon does.

Originally Posted by Michael Cule (Post 1949617)

I think the Stop Thrust is likely to do serious damage to the slammer (I certainly wouldn't rush at someone carrying a pointy thing unless I were wearing damn heavy armour) but the Slam would probably go through with an appropriate penalty for all that pain.

Rules as Written require a Wait to brace for a stop thrust but if you can see the slammer coming I'd say you've got the time to do that. If you're unaware or boggled by surprise then you don't.

So the guy with the flimsy sword's options are:

Stop Thrust and hope you drop him or slow his attack enough that the collision won't matter. Can you also dodge/parry? I'd say not: you're sacrificing that chance to use your enemy's momentum against him. Maybe going for a leg might make better tactical sense.

Dodge. And if you can make it Acrobatic or retreating do so.

Parry. And hope your expensive skinny sword doesn't snap.

Originally Posted by evileeyore (Post 1949702)

Martial Arts p108 has the current Stop Hit rules.

Originally Posted by Railstar (Post 1949762)

Martial Arts p. 106, Dealing With Charging Foes, lists a Parry as giving you a bonus attack. Then uses Holding A Foe at Bay (Quick Contest of ST) for the foe to get closer, so this could represent him charging through the Parry (although he takes the damage first).



I think those are separate from the Stop Thrust rules - because Martial Arts on p. 106 (Dealing With Charging Foes) also refers to using the stop thrust rules on B. p.366 instead of pointing the reader towards p. 108.

Essentially bracing for a Stop Thrust does +1 damage for every 2 squares of speed your opponent is moving at.

Originally Posted by DouglasCole (Post 1949643)

Submitted these a long time ago, so if they pass muster, they'll appear in Pyramid. If not, they'll appear on my blog, but that can be a long time in the dark.

Originally Posted by Railstar (Post 1949762)

Maybe replace the weapon-breakage roll with a ST check?

Originally Posted by Tomsdad (Post 1950137)

Could work, or maybe a skill roll after the parry to see if you retain a ready weapon (penalised by some factor of relative weight)