Re: Quick Question - rules for heavy bows
Quote:
When I mentioned that aristocrats didn't bring their hunting bows to war, I meant in societies where amateur archery, for hunting as a sport, was practised by the aristocracy, but archery was not part of the ideal of the warrior aristocrat in wartime. It was seen like modern football, perhaps, in that some modern military officers might have played high school or even college football and are proud of their football prowess as a peacetime demonstration of martial virtues, but they don't bring a football to war. The societies I'm talking about, in context, were Norman and other French nobles, Saxons, the Welsh, Scots and other societies part of battles where yeoman archers fought. I assumed the context was fairly clear by the way 'yeomanry' was there in the text. In those societies, aristocrats often used bows for sport and probably achieved similar skill as modern hobbyist archers. On a battlefield, that kind of amateur archer does not add any meaningful value to the archers who were raised to shoot heavy warbows. Because even a skilled amateur hunter will not have the experience or capability to shoot as far as the distance between two armies during the maneuvering that happens on a battlefield. There, distances where archers loose might be 200-300 meters, especially for harrying fire, meant to distract and slow the targeted formation. No bow hunter shoots at that kind of range. Their bow doesn't have the power and they don't have the skill to hit at that range, not even when the target is a whole formation. Experiments on how hard it is to hit even large formations of men at a long distance have been performed. Without extensive practice in judging range and adjusting stance to account for it, most people, even skilled bowhunters, don't even hit close enough for the targeted formation to notice that they were the target. The hobbyist skills of bowhunting and the ability to use a warbow as it was used in medieval European warfare are not close enough to each other for the hobbyist bowhunters among the warrior aristocracy to bring their hunting bows to war, any more than a lieutenant in command of a mortar platoon would bring their football to war, even if they played quarterback for the Army Black Knights in college. Quote:
|
Re: Quick Question - rules for heavy bows
Quote:
|
Re: Quick Question - rules for heavy bows
Quote:
|
Re: Quick Question - rules for heavy bows
Quote:
Lots of videos of people shooting heavy bows on YouTube these days eg. Tod's Workshop channel |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:30 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.