Steve Jackson Games Forums - Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

Steve Jackson Games Forums (https://forums.sjgames.com/index.php)

- Munchkin 101 (https://forums.sjgames.com/forumdisplay.php?f=78)

- - Transferral Potion kill or remove monster (https://forums.sjgames.com/showthread.php?t=121749)

Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

FAQ say if I KILL one monster and then someone transfer other monster to other player, I'll get level and treasures for that killed monster anyway.
But if I remove monster (wizard spell, Pollymorth potion...) without killing?

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

You would get the Treasures. Is that what you're asking?

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

Quote:

Originally Posted by MunchkinMan (Post 1702015)

You would get the Treasures. Is that what you're asking?

This answer cancels other answers?
http://forums.sjgames.com/showthread.php?t=76013
http://forums.sjgames.com/showthread.php?t=75973

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

If someone forces you into a second phase of combat after all the monsters from the first phase have been defeated or killed, in a way that did not actually end the fight, and then that second phase of combat is transferred to someone else, that doesn't screw you out of the rewards for the monsters YOU defeated.

That's the official answer.

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

Quote:

Originally Posted by Humulus (Post 1707292)

This answer cancels other answers?
http://forums.sjgames.com/showthread.php?t=76013
http://forums.sjgames.com/showthread.php?t=75973

Yes, that does cancel my previous answers, but we officially changed that answer since January of 2011. I'm surprised that didn't pop up in your search. I'll have to do my own at some point, just to see if it can be found easily enough.

At any rate, I believe that is now answered in the FAQ.

Ah, yes:

Quote:

Originally Posted by The FAQ

Q. I used an ability to automatically kill a monster. Another player used Wandering Monster to add a monster to the fight, and then played Transferral Potion to move the monster to himself. He beat it. Who gets the level and Treasures for the monster I killed?
A. You do; you killed it. (This has been ruled different ways at different times, but we got a ruling directly from Steve, so it trumps everything else.) You get your level and Treasures after the whole combat is resolved. If the other player also wins, you draw Treasures first.

Though it does say "automatically kill," this would apply to Pollymorph Potion, a Wizard's charm spell, or similar cards and abilities.

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

Quote:

Originally Posted by MunchkinMan (Post 1707315)

Though it does say "automatically kill," this would apply to Pollymorph Potion, a Wizard's charm spell, or similar cards and abilities.

what if another player couldn't beat the monster? will I still get levels and treasures?

Re: Transferral Potion kill or remove monster

Quote:

Originally Posted by kotya (Post 2025172)

what if another player couldn't beat the monster? will I still get levels and treasures?

Yes, because you DID kill YOUR monster.