08-16-2011, 03:12 AM | #1 |
GURPS FAQ Keeper
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Kyïv, Ukraine
|
[Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Greetings, all!
In another discussion a poster mentioned that THS memetics is like mind control. I countered by making a real-world example political campaign - a rough approximation for launching 'Vote Putin!' (with -7 for not having memetic software, since psychology TL in Soviet/Post-Soviet space is perhaps as low as 7, and definitely no better than 8). Even when I assumed 2-year planning, and took away the -7 for no memetic program, the results were underwhelming compared to the real-world results (definitely not enough to get a majority vote, perhaps not even enough to get 25%, depending on roll and chosen level of % per MoS). OTOH, I heard whswhs had a moment in a game where he found memetics to be extremely strong. But back then I didn't have the book to see and understand the mechanics behind the event. I'd like to hear opinions on the game-mechanical/world-statistical effects of memetics, arguments why they are considered infallible mind control by some posters, perhaps any murphies etc. Thanks in advance! Last edited by vicky_molokh; 09-01-2011 at 03:30 AM. |
09-01-2011, 04:01 AM | #2 |
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oldenburg, Germany
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
I've never seen Memetics as "magic mind control". When you have the proper amount of data about large numbers of people - which is fairly easy to do in the era of Transhuman Space - it can be very effective at finding just the right hooks for the right people which allow your ideas to spread. But even then, the control you have is statistical, not absolute - the ability to find the right kind of people who are receptive to your message and are also willing to spread it is very useful, but no guarantee of success.
__________________
GURPS Repository • Sunken Castles, Evil Poodles - translating German folk tales into English! |
09-01-2011, 05:03 AM | #3 |
Join Date: Apr 2008
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Two thoughts.
First, memetics is about changing beliefs. If Putin was already popular a "Vote Putin" memetic campaign would have less effect than if he were unpopular - it's pointless preaching to the choir. You need a baseline (i.e. where people would have voted without memetic influence) before you can decide how much influence memetics has. Second, budget (or more generally the amount of media time the memeticist[1] has available) is important. I'm guessing Putin would have had a disproportionate share of TV/radio time (both him directly speaking and general news items talking about him) compared with his rivals. [1] What is the proper term for a professional user of memetics? |
09-01-2011, 09:32 AM | #4 | |
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: U.K.
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Quote:
In truth, I'd be happy to see some more tinkering with the rules for memetics in TS. We probably need more consideration of the baseline population state which the memetics campaign is seeking to modulate, and of the inherent appeal of the object, person, or idea which the campaign is keyed to. On the one hand, if you've got, say, a discontented national population, "This is the strong leader who you're looking for [consciously or not]" can sometimes be astonishingly effective, especially given a charismatic or rhetorically competent leader-figure. And on the other, given an even vaguely typical human population, "Kill your children!" is working against an extremely powerful psychological immune response.
__________________
-- Phil Masters My Home Page. My Self-Publications: On Warehouse 23 and On DriveThruRPG. |
|
09-01-2011, 10:05 AM | #5 |
Untagged
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Forest Grove, Beaverton, Oregon
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
But it wouldn't be stated that way.
It would be something that might eventually lead to death like don't vaccinate your children because it might cause autism, or rely on faith healing instead of modern medicine. |
09-01-2011, 05:04 PM | #6 |
Banned
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bristol
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
I'm not a big fan of Memetics, it appears to do something that something else does but avoids saying that by calling itself Memetics.
If ideas are transferred culturally via Memes and if they are Toxic (seriously how are ideas Toxic and how does it infect your gene pool?) are there antidote or immunisation memes? The problems arise with genetic 'defects' of memes that dictate that the individual is no longer responsible for its actions. The so called 'criminal disposition' because some DNA scientist has 'found' the criminal gene, the driving car fast gene or something totally unfeasable because evolution has not created X because it was created by social means etc. Now to really push the boat out... if memetics is true and it can be activated my surname is Stephens brought to (then) England by the French. Therefore, is there a meme to make me speak and read French (albeit old French)? Now That's taking it back by about 1000 years, so how far back in time does Memes have access to ancient stuff. But let's run with it, it's fun. We will need Meme blockers, Meme enhancers and Meme switches to turn them on and off. What does this do to the individual, you are not who you are but the Genetic combination of past Memes. Hello, Future Shock (no I'm not an Alvin Topher fan). Meme assassination, injecting Memes into people (Dark City?) and is that a genetic assault. What is meant by Toxic? |
09-01-2011, 10:20 PM | #7 | |||
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oldenburg, Germany
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Quote:
And of course there are antidote memes (though immunization is harder). "Don't take drugs!" in all its many variants, for instance, and any other kind of meme that tries to prevent self-destructive behavior (or following a particular ideology, religion, and so forth). None of these are 100% effective, of course. Quote:
But yes, it can be argued that the hosts of particular memes are not in full control of their actions - it was the memes' fault instead. In fact, some memeticists (such as Susan Blackmore, in her "The Meme Machine") go so far and argue that there is no free will, only memes. Certainly, the EU and many other jurisdictions will at least lean into that direction with their emphasis of memetic therapy for offenders over punishment. On the other hand, this means that they feel little hesitation about aiming for true personality changes - after all, the memes someone carries is not a true part of his "self" but more akin to a disease that needs to be cured... Quote:
__________________
GURPS Repository • Sunken Castles, Evil Poodles - translating German folk tales into English! |
|||
09-02-2011, 01:14 AM | #8 |
Banned
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Bristol
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
The next question must be is Meme theory true in this 'verse or just a dominant theory? Are there anti Meme parties?
|
09-02-2011, 01:23 AM | #9 | |
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Lawrence, KS
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Quote:
* As a Fifth Wave society, Montréal had long lifespans, comparatively low fertility, and lots of people who never had children; being a parent was inconvenient and made you a target for social pressure, and many parents had some "buyer's remorse." * There had been a recurring campaign sponsored by Preservationist groups with the theme "Show that you care for the Earth by not having children!" * The woman who designed the campaign "paid the price" by killing her own daughter, and then turning herself in, with a statement of why she did it. The dice roll came up as a modest success. But even having 1-2% of the parents in Montréal decide that killing their children was a good idea struck me as not passing reality testing, besides being way too much for the city's police even to try to cope with, and more than enough to cause widespread terror. So I cut the response rate down to a fraction of 1%, by GM decree, because I simply didn't believe that the outcome of the roll was plausible, even granting an exaggerated effectiveness of memetic methods. Bill Stoddard |
|
09-02-2011, 01:46 AM | #10 | |
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Oldenburg, Germany
|
Re: [Toxic Memes] Memetics: rules, power, effectiveness etc.
Quote:
Certainly child-murders will be on the upswing, but not enough to reach the 1-2% mark. Still, this meme might persist for a long time and make problems for the police, not to mention weaken the fabric of society.
__________________
GURPS Repository • Sunken Castles, Evil Poodles - translating German folk tales into English! |
|
Tags |
crunch, memetics, toxic memes |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|