Munchkin Steampunk: Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour question

NateT · 01-04-2019, 09:37 PM

I have played the Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour card in a combat. This card states: "No further cards can be played in this combat ..."

I have a friend who argues that the one-shots in play in front of her have already been played. There are multiple times that the rules state that one "plays" such cards when they moved from one's hand to one's inventory and that such cards are then "in play". Therefore she argues that she can "use" those cards to modify the combat because she is not "playing" them.

I argue that while these cards were "played" from the hand to the player's inventory (that is, placed "in play") they are then further "played" from inventory into the combat - which is prohibited by the Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour card.

Who's right?

01-04-2019, 09:37 PM	#1
NateT Join Date: Jan 2019	Munchkin Steampunk: Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour question I have played the Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour card in a combat. This card states: "No further cards can be played in this combat ..." I have a friend who argues that the one-shots in play in front of her have already been played. There are multiple times that the rules state that one "plays" such cards when they moved from one's hand to one's inventory and that such cards are then "in play". Therefore she argues that she can "use" those cards to modify the combat because she is not "playing" them. I argue that while these cards were "played" from the hand to the player's inventory (that is, placed "in play") they are then further "played" from inventory into the combat - which is prohibited by the Paramagnetic Fixative Vapour card. Who's right?