Ok, ONE More Transferral Potion vs Magic Lamp Question

[Nobunga]

It is Player A's turn and they're in combat.
Player B uses Transferral Potion to transfer combat to themself.
Player B accepts Player A's Help in combat making Player A the Helper
Could Player A then use Magic Lamp? It is their turn and they're in combat, just not in the usual way.

[Brf]

Since it is Player-A's turn, and he is in combat with the monster, he is fulfilling both requirements for Magic Lamp. I believe the part about "You", meaning Player-A, getting the treasure is wrong though. The Magic Lamp would remove the monster, and the treasure would be split by whatever agreement the players had when Player-A rejoined the combat.

[Nobunga]

Originally Posted by Brf

Since it is Player-A's turn, and he is in combat with the monster, he is fulfilling both requirements for Magic Lamp. I believe the part about "You", meaning Player-A, getting the treasure is wrong though. The Magic Lamp would remove the monster, and the treasure would be split by whatever agreement the players had when Player-A rejoined the combat.

While I value the input of all my discerning Munchkin Fans, I would prefer an Official Ruling on the matter.

[Devin Lewis]

I concur with BRF.