There Can Only Be One vs. Dungeon of Elven Excess

aeronaut · 12-15-2010, 12:08 PM

Searched the forums, even using Chad's advanced google search method, and couldn't find an answer, so I'm asking here. Apologies if this has been answered already.

Player is an elf, and plays "There Can Only Be One" card on his/her elven race. Later, the Dungeon of Elven Excess comes up. How is this resolved?

1) Everyone gets an elf race card while in the dungeon, but upon leaving, must discard it.

2) There can only be one is basically ignored, possibly discarded.

3) Everyone gets an elf race card, and can keep it if it is legal to do so, after the dungeon is left, but no one can add a new elf card after the dungeon is left, because of "There Can Only Be One, ...."

4) The dungeon is discarded and another is drawn (can't see how this would happen unless it's a special ruling from TPTB.)

5) Something else.

Regards,
aeronaut

12-15-2010, 12:08 PM	#1
aeronaut Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Chicago	There Can Only Be One vs. Dungeon of Elven Excess Searched the forums, even using Chad's advanced google search method, and couldn't find an answer, so I'm asking here. Apologies if this has been answered already. Player is an elf, and plays "There Can Only Be One" card on his/her elven race. Later, the Dungeon of Elven Excess comes up. How is this resolved? 1) Everyone gets an elf race card while in the dungeon, but upon leaving, must discard it. 2) There can only be one is basically ignored, possibly discarded. 3) Everyone gets an elf race card, and can keep it if it is legal to do so, after the dungeon is left, but no one can add a new elf card after the dungeon is left, because of "There Can Only Be One, ...." 4) The dungeon is discarded and another is drawn (can't see how this would happen unless it's a special ruling from TPTB.) 5) Something else. Regards, aeronaut __________________ Never Generalize