Floating nose for the win

ShamgarMunchkin · 04-10-2014, 09:14 PM

We ran into a scenario where everyone (six of us) were sitting at a level 9. I kicked in the door and encountered the floating nose. Another player (also 9) was an elf and had the Zombie curse and was forced to help me. There was several monster enhancers and wandering monsters added trying to prevent the win. My helper the elf then played the Halitosis potion instantly killing the floating nose allowing us to be powerful enough to win the combat. Then another player played the friendship potion removing all monsters. We argued that the card said "instantly kill" so we would get the level from the floating nose at least, thus giving us the victory. It was ruled by the GM that since it said "instantly kill the floating nose" that we won and the game was over in a tie with us both winning as my helper was an elf. However if the other player had not played the friendship potion we still would have had to clear the room respectfully following all cards or additional wandering monsters added. Was this the correct ruling?

technically I don't think matters because i successfully convinced everyone that the instant kill was a rule making it a rule. But my curiosity has led me here. haha

04-10-2014, 09:14 PM	#1
ShamgarMunchkin Join Date: Apr 2014	Floating nose for the win We ran into a scenario where everyone (six of us) were sitting at a level 9. I kicked in the door and encountered the floating nose. Another player (also 9) was an elf and had the Zombie curse and was forced to help me. There was several monster enhancers and wandering monsters added trying to prevent the win. My helper the elf then played the Halitosis potion instantly killing the floating nose allowing us to be powerful enough to win the combat. Then another player played the friendship potion removing all monsters. We argued that the card said "instantly kill" so we would get the level from the floating nose at least, thus giving us the victory. It was ruled by the GM that since it said "instantly kill the floating nose" that we won and the game was over in a tie with us both winning as my helper was an elf. However if the other player had not played the friendship potion we still would have had to clear the room respectfully following all cards or additional wandering monsters added. Was this the correct ruling? technically I don't think matters because i successfully convinced everyone that the instant kill was a rule making it a rule. But my curiosity has led me here. haha