Steve Jackson Games - Site Navigation
Home General Info Follow Us Search Illuminator Store Forums What's New Other Games Ogre GURPS Munchkin Our Games: Home

Go Back   Steve Jackson Games Forums > Roleplaying > GURPS

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 06-10-2019, 10:52 PM   #1
Alden Loveshade
 
Alden Loveshade's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Hmm, looks like Earth, circa CE 2020+
Default Perk: Singing based on IQ

Singing is, by default, a HT-based skill. By paying for Attribute Substitution from GURPS Power-Ups 2: Perks pg. 15, do you think it would be valid to base Singing on IQ?
__________________
Kerry Thornley: Dwarf Planet Eris, Discordianism, and The John F. Kennedy Assassination Without Thornley, there would never have been the Steve Jackson Games edition of Principia Discordia
Top 12 Clues You're a Role-Playing Old-Timer My humorous (I hope) article that also promotes SJGames/GURPS
GURPS Fantasy Folk: Elves My first GURPS supplement
Alden Loveshade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2019, 11:01 PM   #2
Refplace
 
Refplace's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Yukon, OK
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Possible, based on HT makes the most sense to me though.
Singing is about projecting properly and knowing how to follow or remember the lyrics. So there is a learned component to it.
However its really a very physical activity, especially if your doing it for awhile.
__________________
My GURPS publications GURPS Powers: Totem and Nature Spirits; GURPS Template Toolkit 4: Spirits; Pyramid articles. Buying them lets us know you want more!
My GURPS fan contribution and blog:
REFPLace GURPS Landing Page
My List of GURPS You Tube videos (plus a few other useful items)
My GURPS Wiki entries
Refplace is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2019, 11:20 PM   #3
whswhs
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Lawrence, KS
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Conceivably, especially for a highly artistic style. But Per might be a closer fit, covering things like sense of pitch.
__________________
Bill Stoddard

I don't think we're in Oz any more.
whswhs is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2019, 11:27 PM   #4
Alden Loveshade
 
Alden Loveshade's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Hmm, looks like Earth, circa CE 2020+
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Quote:
Originally Posted by whswhs View Post
Conceivably, especially for a highly artistic style. But Per might be a closer fit, covering things like sense of pitch.
I must admit I had thought of Per before as a possibility for that very reason, and had forgotten it when I posted. Thanks.
__________________
Kerry Thornley: Dwarf Planet Eris, Discordianism, and The John F. Kennedy Assassination Without Thornley, there would never have been the Steve Jackson Games edition of Principia Discordia
Top 12 Clues You're a Role-Playing Old-Timer My humorous (I hope) article that also promotes SJGames/GURPS
GURPS Fantasy Folk: Elves My first GURPS supplement
Alden Loveshade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2019, 11:31 PM   #5
Alden Loveshade
 
Alden Loveshade's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Hmm, looks like Earth, circa CE 2020+
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Quote:
Originally Posted by Refplace View Post
...Singing is about projecting properly and knowing how to follow or remember the lyrics. So there is a learned component to it...
That's largely the direction I was thinking of, that and following and remembering notes.
__________________
Kerry Thornley: Dwarf Planet Eris, Discordianism, and The John F. Kennedy Assassination Without Thornley, there would never have been the Steve Jackson Games edition of Principia Discordia
Top 12 Clues You're a Role-Playing Old-Timer My humorous (I hope) article that also promotes SJGames/GURPS
GURPS Fantasy Folk: Elves My first GURPS supplement
Alden Loveshade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-10-2019, 11:47 PM   #6
dataweaver
 
dataweaver's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Frankly, Singing is no more of a physical activity than playing a tuba is. I see no problem with basing both Singing and Musical Instrument off of the same attribute — though if I had to pick one, I'd be more likely to go with Perception than either HT or IQ.

But then, I'm also of the opinion that Perception should be the base attribute for most skills that are primarily about aesthetics, whether it's visual (Artist, Makeup, or Photography), auditory (Mimicry, Musical Instrument, Singing, or Ventriloquism), or olfactory (Cooking). Perception works best for each of these because the most important feature is picking up on subtleties in the medium and whether the overall sensory effect is pleasing (attractive visual, pleasant sound, delicious taste, etc) and adjusting accordingly. These skills are all about the sensory experience.
__________________
Point balance is a myth.[1][2][3][4]
dataweaver is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2019, 12:01 AM   #7
JazzJedi
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

I'm of the opinion that Musical Aptitude is more closely related to IQ than any other attribute. I've been a music teacher at university for 20 years, and my brightest students are usually the most musical as well. I've had many students who were seriously athletic (including a professional Hockey player and an Olympic-level cross-country skier) with obvious high HT, but little in the way of musical aptitude. Perception is interesting, but I've never seen any evidence that the ability to relate pitch in any musical sense is related to acuity of hearing. General intelligence seems the most reliable to me, but this isn't always the case either! I've had brilliant students (including a retired heart surgeon and both his kids who all became surgeons) who were clearly high IQ but chronic over-thinkers with very stiff technique and poor musical instincts.

I've also toyed with the idea that Musical Aptitude is basically a rarely used fifth stat that is equal to 10 + Musical Ability level. It's not really worth taking the talent unless you are going to learn 2 or more musical skills. If I ever run a Rock-Opera campaign, or maybe a film-noir campaign with Jazz musicians from the 50s, I'd consider tweaking the rules this way. But unless it's a major campaign theme, I'd base all music skills on IQ and leave it.

But for added realism, I also think that low HT does affect Singing and Wind Instruments especially. Having high HT isn't much of a bonus in my experience, but I've seen older musicians whose health degrades suddenly struggle to play or sing. So maybe the base musical attribute is equal to the lower of 10 or HT. That would cover that.

Last edited by JazzJedi; 06-11-2019 at 12:07 AM.
JazzJedi is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2019, 12:07 AM   #8
Alden Loveshade
 
Alden Loveshade's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Hmm, looks like Earth, circa CE 2020+
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Quote:
Originally Posted by dataweaver View Post
Frankly, Singing is no more of a physical activity than playing a tuba is....But then, I'm also of the opinion that Perception should be the base attribute for most skills that are primarily about aesthetics, whether it's visual (Artist, Makeup, or Photography)....
I've done makeup for theatre, and a lot of photography for newspapers, some for other publications, ceremonies, etc. I hadn't actually thought of it that way, but that makes sense to me. When I'm doing my own makeup, the entire universe is what's in the mirror; when setting up a photo, the entire universe is what's in my viewfinder.

There's the thought that photographers have the delusion "When I'm looking through a camera lens, nothing can hurt me;" I know I've done things looking through a camera lens that I would never do without a camera. I've lain on the ground next to a railroad track to get shots of a train, stood on a narrow railing in the middle of a busy freeway to get a shot of an overturned car, and once almost got caught in a forest fire trying to get the right camera angle. My reasoning mind seemed to largely shut down during those times; it was all about what I could see and record. So yeah, Per makes sense to me.
__________________
Kerry Thornley: Dwarf Planet Eris, Discordianism, and The John F. Kennedy Assassination Without Thornley, there would never have been the Steve Jackson Games edition of Principia Discordia
Top 12 Clues You're a Role-Playing Old-Timer My humorous (I hope) article that also promotes SJGames/GURPS
GURPS Fantasy Folk: Elves My first GURPS supplement
Alden Loveshade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2019, 12:14 AM   #9
Alden Loveshade
 
Alden Loveshade's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Hmm, looks like Earth, circa CE 2020+
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

Quote:
Originally Posted by JazzJedi View Post
I'm of the opinion that Musical Aptitude is more closely related to IQ than any other attribute. I've been a music teacher at university for 20 years, and my brightest students are usually the most musical as well....
I've heard that mathematicians are often good at music and visa versa. If you ignore the (admittedly huge) ascetic side of it, music is largely mathematical with ranges, rhythms, and frequencies/ratios/overtones. A musical staff is essentially a version of a mathematical graph. I also remember a university musical group that consisted of physics professors.
__________________
Kerry Thornley: Dwarf Planet Eris, Discordianism, and The John F. Kennedy Assassination Without Thornley, there would never have been the Steve Jackson Games edition of Principia Discordia
Top 12 Clues You're a Role-Playing Old-Timer My humorous (I hope) article that also promotes SJGames/GURPS
GURPS Fantasy Folk: Elves My first GURPS supplement
Alden Loveshade is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-11-2019, 12:18 AM   #10
a humble lich
 
Join Date: Jun 2017
Default Re: Perk: Singing based on IQ

I think that IQ based singing makes a lot of sense for some characters. I would say it represents a singer who might not have the best sounding voice, but who is a skilled performer. Think singers like Rex Harrison, Bob Dylan, Johnny Rotton, or Tom Waits. They might not have a purest voice for opera, but that hasn't stopped them for selling many albums. That style of singing is really more like Performance, which is IQ based.
a humble lich is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Tags
attribute substitution, perks, power-ups 2, singing

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Fnords are Off
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:52 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.