Is bribing Floating Nose a victory or just automatic Run Away?

[Moldon]

Originally Posted by FAQ

"defeating" a monster involves beating it in combat or removing it from play in such a way that you do not have to Run Away.

If I bribe Floatin Nose - I don't need to Run Away, so I defeat it!
Can I take it's Treasures?

[Grimbriar]

Not sure on this one because it simply says it will let you go.

~summons Andrew~

[Andrew Hackard]

You do not get its Treasure.

[Moldon]

But I realy defeat it?
It may be important for some effects lasting until I defeat a monster

[Gnor]

Originally Posted by Andrew Hackard

You do not get its Treasure.

Hi! The rule book says its a victory! You get the treasure but you dont level up. You took the monster out of the game by its card (bribe). You cant run away so you had 3 option. Defeat, victory with kill, victory without kill. Victory by killing gives treasure and +1 lvl. The bribing give same result like the charming: you neutralised the monster. Rule book confirm the neutralisation as a victory. The card doesnt say you wont get treasure and doesnt say its not a victory, but it called this type of neutralisation as victory. You cant run away but you wasnt in combat. If you cant run, arent beaten, and you neutralised the monster without fight, you cant be looser. Am I right?

[Gnor]

"Sometimes a card will let you get rid of the monster without
killing it. This is still “winning,” but you don’t get a level. Unless
the ability says otherwise, you don’t get the Treasures, either. If the last monster is removed from a combat, it ends instantly."

The hungarian translate says:

"Olykor egy kártya, vagy bizonyos fajból, kasztból eredő képesség lehetővé
illetve magaddal vitt” tárgyakat, csereberélhetsz más játékosokkal és eladhatsz ” teszi, hogy anélkül szabadulj meg egy szörnytől, hogy meg kellene azt ölnöd. dolgokat, hogy megnöveld a szintedet.” Ez is győzelemnek minősül, de ilyenkor nem léphetsz szintet. Sőt, a kártyától függően néha még a kincset sem kapod meg."

The last sentence means: Moreover depending on the card, sometimes you dont get the treasure not either.

It means I ll get the treasure if the card dont say I cant get treasure. The card rule is over the rule book rules but the card dont say I dont get treasure.

What means victory if I dont get anything???

If the nose is the only enemy monster and I m a vinner by "bribe" what will I earn from the combat?

[Andrew Hackard]

Hi and welcome to the Munchkin forums! First: please don't post four messages in a row -- it breaks up the chat and questions/answers get scattered, especially when a couple of the replies just repeat earlier questions (which I have deleted). Once you get a few posts in, you'll have more ways to edit your posts so that doesn't happen.

The other note is always to check the dates before replying to a post, especially in this forum -- if a question is more than a couple of years old, it's possible there are more recent replies to elaborate or even alter answers. It is always worth checking before adding your response or questions. Thanks!

Originally Posted by Gnor

Hi! The rule book says its a victory! You get the treasure but you dont level up. You took the monster out of the game by its card (bribe). You cant run away so you had 3 option. Defeat, victory with kill, victory without kill.

Removing the Floating Nose is a defeat, but the card doesn't say you get any Treasures, so you don't, and you don't get a level because you didn't kill the monster, you bribed it. (Assuming there are no other monsters, which ends combat immediately, or you are able to defeat or kill any monsters that ARE remaining -- Running Away from the other monsters is a loss but you don't have to Run from the Floating Nose because it was already gone.)

Originally Posted by Gnor

"Sometimes a card will let you get rid of the monster without
killing it. This is still “winning,” but you don’t get a level. Unless
the ability says otherwise, you don’t get the Treasures, either. If the last monster is removed from a combat, it ends instantly."

The Hungarian translate says:

I'll stop you there. The Hungarian set was printed several years old and the English rules have been adapted since then. If you're playing Hungarian rules, obviously use those, but we're using English rules on these forums because it's the set most people know and the most sets that have been printed in.