Quote:
Originally Posted by ColBosch
Sure, I get that. But as I've said: do they really need to be targetable? Seriously think about it. I really believe that, if you work through the possible situations and scenarios, you don't need a new rule.
...but I can also dig D5, destroys the bay and anything inside; Vulcans can repair the bay but not the contents. D4 seems a bit weak, and the D8 from the Assault Pack playtest rules is way too much.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by GranitePenguin
Everything external on an ogre is targetable, why not the door to a hold?
D8 is a monster, but at the same time we are talking about something carrying things inside an ogre. It should be freakin' hard to hit.
|
Bowed out early because I never got past needing a 'hard sell' with my own idea, but it's been pretty fascinating watching this one develop. You're both coming at it from a position of 'elegant rules', which given the people involved I'd expect no less, yet opposite directions.
One asks "What does it add to the game, except fiddly rules?", the other asks "Does not having it open an exploit?".