[TheAmishStig]

Against a unit that ignores D results it's effectively the same thing, with the exception for 5-1 [the entire column is Xs]. On the CRT, the number of Xs always changes by 1 going from column to column.

Though it brings up a question...at 3-1 and higher, what is a result of 0? The Battle Box rules don't explicitly say, but I'd imagine the smart move is probably that a roll can't go below 1 or above 6.

Against troops that Ds do affect, it doesn't hold up. NEs double or halve with each step [4-2-1-0-0-0], Xs add or subtract one with each step [1-2-3-4-5-6], then Ds fill in whatever's left...sometimes it's 1 D, sometimes it's 2.

Ogre Minis' rules for Hulks might have an effect on that, because the lowest X leaves a hulk...but the stepped progression should make it a non-issue. Don't quote me on that bit.