[Foril]

ok

so the correct way to deal with this would be:

after the fight

1- player A gives an item that he already has in play to player B

2- player A takes the 2 treasures face down, if one of them is an item, he puts it in play and gives it to player B. if none of them are items (or player A is lying) then the thief gets nothing

I like that, it's a good compromise

thanks and sorry for posting in the wrong forum