Steve Jackson Games Forums - View Single Post

tremorlaine · 12-29-2012, 11:33 AM

Here are the specifics:

Player A is level 9
Player B is level 8 and elf

Player A is fighting a monster with another monster wandered in. She asks for help and player B offers his help because he figures he will win due to getting 2 levels from elf after they defeat both monsters. The monsters were boosted up to a point where Player A played Magic Lamp to poof one of them. They are now winning the combat and I want to smack Player B. Alas we cannot stop the combat so Player A wins.

Does Player B get one level or two since he helped against two monster and technically they were both defeated?

I ruled that he only gets one since Player A single-handedly defeated one of them with the Magic Lamp. What made me shake my head in disgust is that Player A had the Magic Lamp on the table in plain sight.

12-29-2012, 11:33 AM	#1
tremorlaine Join Date: Oct 2012	Elf question Here are the specifics: Player A is level 9 Player B is level 8 and elf Player A is fighting a monster with another monster wandered in. She asks for help and player B offers his help because he figures he will win due to getting 2 levels from elf after they defeat both monsters. The monsters were boosted up to a point where Player A played Magic Lamp to poof one of them. They are now winning the combat and I want to smack Player B. Alas we cannot stop the combat so Player A wins. Does Player B get one level or two since he helped against two monster and technically they were both defeated? I ruled that he only gets one since Player A single-handedly defeated one of them with the Magic Lamp. What made me shake my head in disgust is that Player A had the Magic Lamp on the table in plain sight.